80.X Lineage Outline

Last updated 11/18/2026

This is an expanded version of Pleromism and a written account of the visual genealogy.

Orientation

Pleromism aims toward an integrated theory and method to use for research on inequity oriented toward totality.

The heart of Pleromism most strongly reflects W. E. B. Du Bois' seminal 1899 work, The Philadelphia Negro. In the wake of contemporary social ills like poverty, alcoholism, and crime, Du Bois set out to study the conditions of Black individuals living in Philadelphia with a dizzying scope. As part of his analysis, he deemed it necessary to also explore the quality of housing, education, employment, and a variety of other seemingly irrelevant factors because "the removal of unpleasant features from our complicated modern life is a delicate operation" (Chapter 2, Section 4). Eliminating problems without addressing all the complexities that bring them forward will simply result in their manifestation elsewhere. Therefore, social inequity is impossible to understand without a systematic consideration of the interrelated historical, cultural, and political factors it is the result of.

Generally speaking, this work considers inquiry focused on specific aspects of domination to be part of a larger whole rather than the means to an end.[1] Instead, Pleromism draws from connections among a few different academic fields in order to analyze the components that make up the social order and the dynamic mechanisms of power that shaped it. British Cultural Studies offers insight into how the experiences of individuals are interpreted and defined by power, particularly as it relates to the relations between dominant and subordinate groups in society. Western Marxism provides conceptual support for how dominant forces maintain their position through holistic analysis. Post-Structuralism offers philosophical considerations on the constructed nature of knowledge and reality, which is further supplemented by Science & Technology Studies and the interest-driven nature of rationality found embedded in everyday objects.

This section will expand on the contributions from these (and other) fields in order to answer the following questions:

  1. What processes of social relations and conflict constructed society?
  2. How does individual and group subjectivity form?
  3. What collective forces prevent or enable change to the status quo?

Pleromic Analysis describes the employable research methods to analyze these components in a given situation. Pleromic Analysis is largely built from the tradition of Critical Discourse Analysis in the styles of Blommaert and Laclau & Mouffe.


1. Power

Power is the force that shapes social relations and manifests in many ways. It is responsible for the network of boundaries that determine what we can or cannot do, but what is the form of power in its fullest sense? This section will build out a typology of power.

Negotiators: Active Power

Power used by actors for domination was developed as the 'three dimensions of power.' This tradition begins with a formula established by Robert Dahl, where A gets B to do something they wouldn't otherwise do.

The three dimensions of power are helpful to represent the various active processes of power to constrict what is possible for that who is on the receiving end. However, this alone is insufficient. Critiques include:

Because of these limits, we will now consider a parallel tradition of thought.

Emitters: Passive Power

The work of Michel Foucault makes the case that power can be productive just as it is oppressive. It is diffuse and shapes who people are and what they choose to do. Knowledge creates individual subjectivity and as a result the social order, which is materialized in techniques, organizations, roles, etc.

The throughline among these thinkers is that people are shaped not just by active domination, but we constantly participate in a world that shapes who we are whether we realize it or not. This contradicts the idea that power is inherently negative and is instead contingent on how it is used.

Regardless, this characterization of power has also been met with critique:

Such questions may be reconciled with one more concept.

Capacitors: Potential Power

Bourdieu extends the concept of capital beyond merely that of economic means. Cultural, symbolic, and social capital can all enable one's ability to shape social relations (i.e., use mechanisms of power). We can understand such capital to not necessarily be power itself; rather, money, relationships, credentials, and so on are accumulative potential for power.

Conduits: Vessels and Targets of Power

Finally, we must who or what is responsible for mechanisms of power if people do not 'hold' power. Applying the tradition of social constructionism to the types of power that have been discussed, we understand that components like institutions and cultures are simultaneously outlets for and targets of power. Individuals are outlets for and targets of power.

These ideas lead us back to reinforce the conceptualization of power described by Clarissa Hayward at the beginning of this section: power is the network of social boundaries that shape possible action.


2. Collectives

We just discussed power's effects resulting in a network that defines what is or is not possible: this network constitutes a Realm of Freedom. It includes what is normal, good, legal, rational, and other qualifiers that, if violated, would result in the individual facing consequences.

Realms

While the previous section on power is applicable to the context of both individuals and collectives, there are additional factors to consider for collectives. Because individual Realms can significantly differ among those who are part of a group (i.e., a different configuration of their Conduits), a new consciousness in the form of a Collective Realm emerges.

Max Weber again highlights the interrelatedness of culture and institutions in his analysis of Protestant values on the economic system of Capitalism. Of course, not every individual subject to this economic system is Protestant, but all must participate in it.

Myths

We have some explanation, from Power Capacitors, that certain individuals or groups have a greater ability to shape the boundaries of themselves and others. That also includes influence on the Collective Realm. But what compels groups to dominate other groups in a collective instead of percieving them as equals?

Here we must consider the contributions, awkward as they may be, of Structuralism. Ferdinand de Saussure identified how common structures or patterns of thought recurred throughout societies, and Claude Lévi-Strauss applied these ideas to study how universal stories and myths can be broken down into fundamental relations between a function and a subject based on the originating culture.

The point is, myths helps groups rationalize the world around them. They take historical meaning and present it as natural (Roland Barthes). Because collectives are composed of contradictory elements, myths are symbolic resolutions of these contradictions (Frederic Jameson) and can suture the dislocated social order (Laclau and Mouffe).

Mythoscapes

Myths do not just exist in isolation, though. They form systems of thought for a particular perspective to organize meaning and rationalize the world.

Collective Realms

Now that components of Realms are understood as infinite sets of circles within circles... we can now identify what the dominant Realm in a collective is, or rather what it excludes. J. Milton Yinger's work in methodologically defining countercultures show how groups that define their system of norms in explicit opposition to the mainstream illuminate what is 'not acceptable.'

This logic is paralleled and expanded on by Stuart Hall, who more explicitly engaged with Marxism and rejected the mainstream Parsonian sociological tradition in the United States. His work in Cultural Studies demonstrated how even subcultures exposes and resist dominant culture by distinguishing themselves.


3. Stability

The final piece to social relations are the processes by which a Collective Realm retains its shape and resists significant change. Even without a particular 'ruling class,' even without intent, the status quo largely enforces existing relationships between groups in society through six processes. These six processes are distinct but at times have overlapping functions.

Note that as a stylistic choice to avoid some harms of over-rationalized science, this research refers to the social processes listed below as though they are mythological cosmic deities - the Realm Enforcers :)

First, Monadus represents hegemony, as described by Antonio Gramsci and expanded on by Stuart Hall. This is the process by which a certain representation of a collective takes a leading, defining position. This leadership is not quite domination; it has the capacity to contain, educate, and reshape oppositional forces without removing them entirely. It manifests as the common-sense assumptions and the taken-for-granted.

Second, Mithrot represents the process by which we imbue meaning in myths. Myths are detotalizing in nature, since they represent one perspective. By representing patterns, they also tend to oversimplify the situations they are symbols of. Thirdly, their form can be copied even if substance is changed. Some examples of the latter appropriation or "mythdirection" include:

Third, Categorius represents the process by which we imbue meaning in classified knowledge. As described by Foucault, the subjectification of people produces who they become, at which point governments exert biopower to manage those populations. It also represents the dividing practices or binaries leveraged in myth.

Fourth, Rationaliza represents the process by which the status quo is normalized, justified, or otherwise made out to be the superior or only option. This was partially discussed with earlier reference to symmetry, but also includes:

Fifth, Distributon represents the process by which resources are allocated among members in a collective. Because our society's economic system is structured such that wealth or debt accumulates, Distributon is currently split into two forms: Hoarde and Deprivas.

Sixth, Repressio represents the process by which unacceptable terms in a collective are limited. This can occur through visible force (e.g., imprisonment, silencing), or in more subtle forms. The later could look like repressive desublimation from Herbert Marcuse, where desires and oppositions are allowed but defanged, or implicit censorship from Judith Butler, where the unspeakable is ruled out before it is spoken.

It is possible that the listed Enforcers have more functions than described. It is also possible there are more than six Enforcers. This is just an early attempt at weaving together similarly-minded concepts that appear to be describing related functions.

Anyway. So the whole point of all of this is... if people want a different kind of society - a more equitable kind, hopefully - these six processes are what they would need to contend with. Knowing is half the battle, I suppose.

And we just might be able to get some hints from other sources...



  1. I am referring broadly to intellectual traditions of classical Marxism and identity-based Critical Theory (e.g., DisCrit, Critical Race Theory, Critical Feminist Theory) here. To clarify, I am not denying the insights of how class relations are situated in economic structures or how particular subpopulations experience disproportionate harms, but I do not believe in their primacy. Discussion on the reductive nature of economic determinism is most prevalent across Western Marxism (Perry Anderson, Considerations on Western Marxism, 1976). For concise extensions of this argument, see also Hall (Cultural Studies 1983: A Theoretical History, Lecture 4, 2016); or Laclau and Mouffe (Hegemony and Socialist Strategy, Introduction, 1985). ↩︎